FROM THE PULPIT

When concern turns into condemnation (Part II)

By Yusuf Bulafu

Cont’d …

A Muslim cannot carry the final outcome of another person’s guidance upon his shoulders, because guidance ultimately belongs to Allah and human beings remain accountable for their own choices.

Even the Messenger could deeply love someone, teach him, reason with him, pray for his guidance, and still remain unable to place faith inside his heart.

Our responsibility therefore concerns what lies within our reach: teaching clearly, advising wisely, creating healthy environments, removing unnecessary barriers, showing mercy, answering questions, correcting harmful behavior, and remaining available when people want to return.

This protects concern from turning into an impossible burden. We should neither abandon people because their choices belong to them nor imagine that their salvation rests entirely upon us. The balanced Muslim carries responsibility intensely while recognizing his limits humbly.

He works as though his effort matters enormously, then entrusts hearts and final outcomes to Allah.

Such a principle becomes especially demanding for teachers, parents, imams, community leaders, and anyone involved in Islamic work. It is easy for institutions to count the people who stopped attending while rarely investigating why they disappeared. Parents can describe children as rebellious without asking whether communication at home made honesty frightening.

Teachers can complain that students lack seriousness while offering learning environments that never awaken curiosity or belonging. Mosques can lament the absence of young Muslims while providing few roles through which young people can participate, serve, and mature. None of these examples automatically makes the institution responsible for every individual decision, but each creates a duty of examination.

Before saying that people have become ruined, leadership should ask what was available to prevent that ruin. Religious responsibility reaches beyond issuing correct judgments after failure. It requires anticipating weakness and building pathways through which people can remain connected before the crisis arrives.

This perspective also changes how Muslims speak about sinners and struggling believers. Repeated labels can slowly imprison people inside the identities we assign them. Someone who constantly hears that he is corrupt, hopeless, unserious, or part of a ruined generation may eventually conclude that religious people have already decided what he is capable of becoming.

Daʿwah then loses an essential resource: hope. The believer should be able to recognize serious wrongdoing while leaving the door of return visibly open. Every person we criticize today may become better than us tomorrow, and every weakness we notice in another person may exist in a different form within ourselves.

The language of reform therefore needs truth together with humility. We should name destructive behavior clearly, protect communities from harm, and maintain moral standards without speaking as though people have crossed beyond the reach of transformation. A Muslim concerned with guidance sees present failure as a condition requiring response, rather than a permanent identity deserving contempt.

Perhaps this is where the hadith can reshape the culture of Muslim communities deeply. We have become accustomed in many settings to measuring seriousness by how strongly someone condemns what has gone wrong.

Another measure deserves attention: what has that person built so that fewer people go wrong tomorrow? If we say young people are losing Islam, where are the spaces that answer their questions? If families are breaking, where is the preparation that teaches people how to build healthy homes?

If Muslims are distant from knowledge, where are the accessible pathways that bring serious learning into ordinary lives? If people repeatedly fall into sin, where are the communities that combine accountability with companionship and restoration? This should therefore leave us uncomfortable with spectatorship.

The Muslim character we need sees another person approaching ruin and feels summoned to act. Before declaring that people are lost, we should ask a harder question: what have we placed in their path to help them find their way home?

 

 

Related Articles

Back to top button